Fungi can be notoriously difficult to identify, with many species looking remarkably similar and some requiring a closer look at features that aren’t always obvious in a photograph. So, how do the main identification apps fare when faced with something altogether more challenging than your average Fly Agaric? Let’s take a look at the best fungi apps, shall we?
In my last post comparing the best plant identification apps, I looked at eight of the most popular AI-powered apps on the market. That post has proved insanely popular but, thinking back, I suspect we were a little kind to the apps on that occasion, with most of the species used fairly easy and recognisable. After all, identifying something from a photograph is one thing, but getting to grips with some of our trickier species is quite another.

Fungi present a particularly interesting challenge for identification apps. With thousands of species to choose from, many of which can look remarkably alike, even experienced mycologists can find themselves scratching their heads. Features such as gill attachment, spore colour, bruising reactions and microscopic characteristics can all be important, yet aren’t necessarily visible in your average photograph. It’s little wonder that casual enthusiasts turn to identification apps for a helping hand. But can they be trusted? That’s what we’ll aim to test in this post.
Of the many identification apps available, a few names crop up again and again. Most people will have heard of Obsidentify, PictureThis or Google Lens. Others, such as Shroomify, are perhaps a little more obscure, but all aim to do much the same thing. The question is: are any of them truly any good?
First, some ground rules
Just like last time, and to standardise our little fungi identification experiment, I’ve introduced a few rules to keep things fair:
- One image only. While some apps allow you to upload multiple photographs, we wouldn’t want to give any one of them an unfair advantage, would we?
- Clear images. We’ll only use clear photographs showing enough of the fungus to give the apps a reasonable chance of reaching an accurate identification.
- British fungi. I’ve chosen species that are commonly found in Britain, making the test more relevant to British fungi enthusiasts.
This time, I thought I’d make things a bit more challenging for our candidate identification apps by including several different groups of fungi. Rather than simply testing them on a selection of familiar toadstools, we’ll be looking at a mixture of mushrooms, brackets, corals and other fungi. That should really test their mettle…
I’ve also decided to include species with varying levels of identification difficulty. Some have distinctive features that should make them relatively straightforward to recognise, while others are considerably more challenging, even for those with a little mycological experience. After all, there’s little point testing identification apps on something unmistakable.
Meet the subjects
I’ve selected the ten fungi below based on their varying levels of difficulty. Some should be relatively straightforward for the apps to identify, while others may prove considerably more of a challenge. I’ve deliberately included a few trickier species, where distinguishing between similar-looking fungi requires a closer examination of the finer details. The inclusion of the slightly mangled Oily Waxcap is admittedly a bit mean, but hey, this is my blog, and we’re here to really put these fungi identification apps to the test, aren’t we?

Aleuria aurantia

Geastrum triplex

Hygrocybe quieta

Clavulinopsis corniculata

Lacrymaria lacrymabunda

Clitocybe fragrans

Coprinellus micaceus

Gymnopilus junonius

Phaeolus schweinitzii

Bolbitius titubans
Comparing Fungi Apps
For comparison’s sake, we’ll stick with a similar scoring system to the one used in the previous posts. Any fungi identification app that correctly identifies the fungus as its first choice will receive 1 point. If the correct species appears further down the list, points will be deducted based on its position. For example, if the correct species appears as the fourth suggestion, it would earn 0.6 points. I may also award bonus points in certain cases if an app manages to genuinely impress me. With all of this in mind, here are the scores…
| Orange-peel Fungus Aleuria aurantia | Collared Earthstar Geastrum triplex | Oily Waxcap Hygrocybe quieta | Meadow Coral Clavulinopsis corniculata | Weeping Widow Lacrymaria lacrymabunda | Fragrant Funnel Clitocybe fragrans | Glistening Inkcap Coprinellus micaceus | Spectacular Rustgill Gymnopilus junonius | Dyer’s Mazegill Phaeolus schweinitzii | Yellow Fieldcap Bolbitius titubans | Score (0-10) | |
| Obsidentify | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✘ | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | 9/10 |
| Shroomify | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✘ | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔0.7 | ✘ | ✘ | ✔1 | 6.7/10 |
| Picture This | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✘ | ✘ | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | 8/10 |
| ShroomID | ✔1 | ✔0.7 | ✘ | ✘ 0.5 for family | ✔1 | ✔0.9 | ✔0.7 | ✔0.9 | ✔1 | ✔1 | 7.7/10 |
| PictureMushroom | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | 10/10 |
| Google Lens | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✘ | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | ✔1 | 9/10 |
Well, that was not what I was expecting! It seems that all of the apps we trialled are pretty good at identifying fungi. AI really has come a long way in recent years. Still, there has to be a winner, and this time around, with a perfect score, it’s Picture Mushroom! Closely followed by ObsIdentify and Google Lens, I must say.
I have to admit, I was rather impressed by the results overall. Fungi identification is no easy task, even for experienced mycologists, so it’s encouraging to see these apps performing so well. That said, a good score in our little experiment doesn’t necessarily mean an app will always get things right. Treat those suggestions as a helpful starting point rather than a definitive identification, particularly when it comes to anything you might be tempted to eat!
The Losers (though not really that bad)

Shroomify (6.7/10)
Not really that bad…
Shroomify is actually quite an intuitive little app that encourages active learning and has been developed with UK fungi enthusiasts in mind. It’s easy to use, and the prompts encouraging you to explore other features of your mushroom are particularly good for developing a more methodical approach to identification.
Still, this was a test of AI-assisted quick identification, and Shroomify did come last. Getting the Oily Waxcap wrong is perhaps understandable, but the Dyer’s Mazegill, perhaps less so.
I like the educational approach, but if you’re looking for quick AI-assisted identification, I’d probably go for one of the other options instead.
ShroomID (7.7/10)
It actually feels bad calling this one a loser…
This is actually a pretty good app, and I suspect it would have fared even better had I done what I was supposed to and uploaded photographs of the various parts of each mushroom. That wasn’t allowed for the purposes of our little experiment, however!
Even where ShroomID got things wrong, it was usually pretty close, often suggesting the correct species further down the list. Of course, that pesky Oily Waxcap caught it out, while being the only app to struggle with Meadow Coral cost it a few more marks.
In fact, my only real gripe with this one is just how heavily it pushes its paid subscription. I eventually ran out of free identifications and found myself locked out of the results for 24 hours. A little frustrating when you’re in the middle of a fungi identification spree!
PictureThis (8/10)
Now I just feel like I am being mean…
PictureThis is a popular app, widely used for plant identification, where it performs jolly well. I confess, I didn’t even realise it could identify fungi too! I don’t really have anything particularly negative to say about it, in truth, although its struggle with Meadow Coral was a bit of a surprise.
It’s easy to use, straightforward and generally rather good at what it does. Still, while there’s plenty to like, there are better options out there if fungi identification is your main priority.
Better Choices

Obsidentify (9/10)
A solid choice, popular with naturalists…
ObsIdentify was one of the strongest performers in our little experiment, scoring an impressive 9/10. It got almost everything right, with the Oily Waxcap being its only real stumbling block. That’s perhaps a little unfair, as identifying waxcaps from a photograph of the cap alone can be tricky, with features such as the gills and stem often needed to clinch an identification.
There’s plenty to like about ObsIdentify. It’s easy to use, quick, completely free and specifically designed with European wildlife in mind. Its extensive database draws on millions of observations, and it’s particularly nice to see an app that encourages users to contribute their own records to biological recording.
All in all, a very impressive little app and one I’d happily recommend. It’s certainly the one I use most often.
GoogleLens (9/10)
Getting better all the time, and very nearly perfect…
Google Lens was another strong performer, scoring 9/10 and matching ObsIdentify almost exactly. It correctly identified all but the Oily Waxcap, which, as we’ve already established, is perhaps a little harsh.
There’s not a great deal to say about Google Lens that most people won’t already know. It’s incredibly easy to use, quick, free and has the added advantage of drawing on a huge range of online images and resources. Unlike dedicated identification apps, it can also point you towards websites and other sources to explore your find further.
It’s not infallible, of course, and its suggestions can sometimes be a little hit and miss, but it performed well here.

PictureMushroom (10/10)
A perfect score…
Well, I wasn’t expecting this! Picture Mushroom scored a perfect 10/10, correctly identifying every single species in our test, including the notoriously troublesome Oily Waxcap. That’s quite an achievement, and makes it a very worthy winner.
As far as fungi apps go, there’s plenty to like about this one. It’s easy to use, produces results quickly and offers much more than just a name. Each identification comes with useful information about the species, including its habitat, distinguishing features and potential toxicity. You can also explore similar species, browse identification guides and keep a collection of your finds.
Looking at other user reviews, I’m clearly not alone in being impressed. Users regularly praise its identification accuracy, extensive species information and straightforward interface. Some particularly like the ability to compare several suggested species rather than simply accepting the first result.
I must say, I’m rather tempted by this one! It performed brilliantly in our little experiment and looks like a genuinely useful companion for anyone interested in fungi.